Best Books3

The First Witch of Boston

by Andrea Catalano
 The First Witch of Boston by Andrea Catalano historical fiction novel about Salem, suspicion, fear, and women's resilience book cover

Praise For This Book


"Catalano's character and world-building ably bring to life an era fueled by superstition, repression, and intolerance...I can see this book appealing to the many fans of Ariel Lawhon's The Frozen River and Chris Bohjalian's Hour of the Witch, and eagerly look forward to reading whatever Catalano writes next." -Historical Novels Review

"Fans of The Frozen River will love The First Witch of Boston! Fiery, outspoken Margaret Jones and her husband, Thomas, find themselves outliers in straitlaced Puritan Boston, but trouble back in England leaves them no choice but to make a home in Massachusetts. When Thomas draws the spite of a local widow and Margaret's skill with healing herbs rouses suspicion of black magic, both will find themselves battling witch-hunters in a court case destined to make history. Andrea Catalano draws a tender, intimate portrait of a marriage and a bold defense of an independent woman ahead of her time." -Kate Quinn, New York Times bestselling author of The Rose Code

"A sumptuous and heartrending tale of the dark power of fear, loss, and love against all odds, The First Witch of Boston is a moving and accomplished debut." -Heather Webb, USA Today bestselling author of Queens of London

"I knew I was going to love this novel from the first page, where Andrea Catalano immerses you in the world of seventeenth-century Boston. Her research is impeccable but never gets in the way of a gripping, emotional story. Thomas Jones's love for his outspoken, opinionated wife, Maggie, and hers for him, are beautifully described, and their tragedy is almost Shakespearean. This is a story that will stay with me for a long time." -Gill Paul, internationally bestselling author of Scandalous Women

"Andrea Catalano's The First Witch of Boston conjures the treacherous history of witches, women, and injustice in America. Her research is ambitious and beyond impeccable. But it is the exquisite portrayal of a marriage that is the star at the beating heart of this novel, and the best I've read in years." -Kimberly Brock, bestselling author of The Fabled Earth and The Lost Book of Eleanor Dare

"Catalano's timely and heart-wrenching treatise about the injustices against women in early America will leave traces etched in the reader's soul. Sensory, sensual, and evocative, The First Witch of Boston is the not-to-be-missed historical fiction debut of the season." -Aimie K. Runyan, bestselling author of The School for German Brides and Mademoiselle Eiffel

"What a wonderful, moving novel. Catalano's debut is great historical fiction that brings the past alive in an exquisitely human, truly emotional way. I absolutely loved it." -Megan Chance, bestselling author of Glamorous Notions

"A brilliant debut, full of passion, peril, and heartbreak. Between her gorgeous prose and her endearing characters, Andrea Catalano has established herself as one of the most exciting new authors in historical fiction." -Olivia Hawker, bestselling author of One for the Blackbird, One for the Crow

"A rare and powerful debut-one that will hold you in thrall from beginning to end. Catalano gives voice to all the passion, anguish, and injustice surrounding the life and death of a woman who deserved a better fate than the one history dealt her. Lyrically written and impeccably researched, The First Witch of Boston settles into the deepest places in your soul, and remains there long after finishing. An artful, important masterpiece of historical fiction." -Paulette Kennedy, bestselling author of The Witch of Tin Mountain




Four plus years of book club picks
Looking for your next group read? Explore 4+ years of curated picks that actually spark a conversation ....




More Must-Read Books

Book Summary -  Daughters of the Sun and Moon by Lisa See

Daughters of the Sun and Moon

By Lisa See
Beloved New York Times bestselling author Lisa See draws on the vibrancy and turmoil of post-Civil War Los Angeles to tell the story of three Chinese women who managed to survive and, eventually, thrive, despite all odds. ...More

 Book Review - The Book Witch
by Meg Shaffer

The Book Witch

By Meg Shaffer
She can hop into any novel, she just can't stay there. Come along with the book witch in this magical and inspiring love letter to reading from the USA Today bestselling author of The Wishing Game ... More
Book Review -  Keeper of Lost Children
by Sadeqa Johnson

Keeper of Lost Children

By Sadeqa Johnson
In this new novel from the New York Times bestselling author of The House of Eve, one American woman's vision in post WWII Germany will tie together three people in an unexpected way....More

 Book Review - My Husband's Wife
by Alice Feeney

My Husband's Wife

By Alice Feeney
The New York Times bestselling Queen of Twists is back with a psychological masterpiece that will leave you questioning everything you know about love, identity, and revenge. By the author of His & Hers, now a #1 Netflix show!... More

You May Also Like:

Historical Fiction Books We loved From our website- Favorite bestsellers- NY Times Indie Picks, Celebrity Picks

Visit Our Blog

5 Star Reads
Most Antipipated Books of 2026 ..... Our Favorites.


PBR book reviews and Reading guides for book clubs
10 Books I Can't Stop Recommending
Book blog- Immersive reads