Best Books3

The Girl Who Came Home

by Hazel Gaynor
Cover of 'The Girl Who Came Home' by Hazel Gaynor, a Titanic historical fiction novel about Irish emigrants from Addergoole, Ireland; ideal for book clubs

Book Review

Five star rating
(by Andrea)
I listened to the audio version of this book and it was excellent. It gave me a deeper understanding of what happened on that terrible day when the Titanic sank.

Gaynor offers a fresh perspective by focusing on the rural community of Addergoole, Ireland, which sent fourteen people on the ship, of whom only three survived. She weaves a captivating love story while vividly depicting the passengers' experiences.

What impressed me most was the lack of sensationalism. The scenes of the crew lowering lifeboats are mesmerizing. The fear and apprehension among passengers searching for loved ones feel palpable. From beginning to end, this book held my interest, striking a balance between historical fiction and romance. It won the 2015 Romantic Novelists' Association award and would make a great book club selection.

Book Summary

William Morrow Paperbacks - Historical Fiction - 362 pages

Inspired by true events, The Girl Who Came Home follows a group of Irish emigrants aboard RMS Titanic.

Ireland, 1912. Seventeen year old Maggie Murphy leaves her sweetheart Seamus behind when she boards Titanic with fellow villagers. Disaster strikes and Maggie is one of the few steerage passengers to survive.

Chicago, 1982. Grace Butler struggles after her father's death. When her great grandmother Maggie reveals the secret she has hidden since Titanic, Grace gains new direction and the chance to reconnect with the past.

Book Club Talking Points

There is a wealth of information about the Titanic, but this story adds a personal and immediate lens. What the characters experience onboard feels vivid and discussion worthy. The aftermath of surviving such a tragedy raises questions about memory, guilt, and resilience that book clubs will want to explore.

Discussion Questions

1. We know Titanic's fate. How does this knowledge shape your feelings as the Ballysheen group boards the ship?

2. Discuss Kathleen Dolan's influence on Maggie and the other emigrants.

3. Grace sacrifices her education to help her mother. How does this compare to Maggie's sacrifices in 1912?

4. As the events of April 14 unfold, who are you most invested in and why?

5. How do superstition and myth color the story of Titanic?

6. Did this book change how you think about the ordeal after leaving the ship?

7. Discuss relationships such as Grace and Maggie; Maggie and Seamus; Maggie and Aunt Kathleen.

8. Emigration split many Irish families. How would you weigh such a decision today?

9. Why does Titanic still fascinate more than a century later?

10. What are your thoughts on recreating Titanic's maiden voyage in modern times?

Discussion Questions by the publisher

Four plus years of book club picks
Looking for your next group read? Explore 4+ years of curated picks that actually spark a conversation ....




More Must-Read Books

Book Summary -  Daughters of the Sun and Moon by Lisa See

Daughters of the Sun and Moon

By Lisa See
Beloved New York Times bestselling author Lisa See draws on the vibrancy and turmoil of post-Civil War Los Angeles to tell the story of three Chinese women who managed to survive and, eventually, thrive, despite all odds. ...More

 Book Review - The Book Witch
by Meg Shaffer

The Book Witch

By Meg Shaffer
She can hop into any novel, she just can't stay there. Come along with the book witch in this magical and inspiring love letter to reading from the USA Today bestselling author of The Wishing Game ... More
Book Review -  Keeper of Lost Children
by Sadeqa Johnson

Keeper of Lost Children

By Sadeqa Johnson
In this new novel from the New York Times bestselling author of The House of Eve, one American woman's vision in post WWII Germany will tie together three people in an unexpected way....More

 Book Review - My Husband's Wife
by Alice Feeney

My Husband's Wife

By Alice Feeney
The New York Times bestselling Queen of Twists is back with a psychological masterpiece that will leave you questioning everything you know about love, identity, and revenge. By the author of His & Hers, now a #1 Netflix show!... More

You May Also Like:

Historical Fiction Books We loved From our website- Favorite bestsellers- NY Times Indie Picks, Celebrity Picks

Visit Our Blog

5 Star Reads
Most Antipipated Books of 2026 ..... Our Favorites.


PBR book reviews and Reading guides for book clubs
10 Books I Can't Stop Recommending
Book blog- Immersive reads