Best Books3

The Witch of Wall Street

by Marie Benedict
 The Witch of Wall Street by Marie Benedict book cover – book club discussion questions about Hetty Green, ambition, independence, and women in Gilded Age America.

Discussion Questions

Need a quick refresher before your meeting? Read The Witch of Wall Street Book Summary


Behind The Book:
Marie Benedict's The Witch of Wall Street is inspired by the remarkable life of Hetty Green (1834–1916), one of the wealthiest women in American history. Known as the "Witch of Wall Street," Green built an extraordinary fortune in the male-dominated financial world of the Gilded Age, a time when women had few opportunities to control their own money, let alone compete with the country's most powerful businessmen.

However, beneath the stories was a woman who truly understood money and chose to live by her own rules, not by what society expected. Green's story also raises an interesting question: Would a man with the same financial instincts and ruthless determination have been judged quite so harshly?
+ Host Icebreakers
Ice Breaker Question:
Hetty Green was admired for her financial brilliance but criticized for her ambition and frugality. Do you think she was judged more harshly because she was a woman, or were some of those criticisms justified?
+ Spoiler & Content Warnings
Spoiler Alert:
The discussion questions below are spoiler-free. Check back closer to the March 2, 2027 publication date for our complete set of book club discussion questions, where we'll take a deeper look at Hetty's relationships, difficult choices, and the moments that reveal the woman behind the legend. The full guide will contain spoilers and is intended for readers who have finished the book

Content Warning:
No content warnings for The Witch of Wall Street.
Book Club Questions By Princeton Book Review
Our The Witch of Wall Street book club questions explore Hetty Green's ambition, choices, relationships, and the expectations placed on women of her time. Use these discussion questions to spark meaningful conversations at your next book club meeting.
1. The press and Hetty's competitors called her "The Witch of Wall Street." Why do you think this name stuck? If a man had built the same wealth using the same methods, would people have praised him as a smart genius instead?

2. Hetty took on Wall Street giants like Carnegie and Morhan, often succeeding where they didn't. What gave her an advantage over these powerful men? Was it her financial judgement, patience, willingness to take risks, or something else? Which conforntation stood out to you the most?

3. Hetty pioneered value investing-buying undervalued assets when others panicked and holding large cash reserves. Warren Buffett follows the same approach today. Why do you think people mocked her methods in her time but celebrate them now? Do you think her gender affected how people judged her strategy?

4. How did Hetty's Quaker upbringing influence her choices around money, spending, and how she presented herself? Did her famous frugality come across as principle, habit, or self-protection?

5. A core theme of the novel is the cost of pursuing wealth. What did Hetty sacrifice for her fortune, and do you think she would say it was worth it?

6. Marie Benedict chllenges the historical portrayal of Hetty Green as cold, miserly,and ruthless. How much of Hetty's reputation do you think was shaped by the expectations of her time? Did the novel make you question how hisoru has remembered othe accompliched women?

+ The Witch of Wall Street Read-Alikes
Looking for books like The Witch of Wall Street? These historical fiction read-alikes share themes of courageous women, survival, resilience, and defying expectations.
The Personal LIbrarian by Marie Benedict & Victoria Christopher Murray
A historical novel about Belle da Costa Greene, who manages J.P.Morgan's library while hiding a secret that could ruin her career.

A Founding Mother by Stephanie Dray & Laura Kamoie
A fascinating look at an influential woman of early America, whose intelligence, determination, and political insight challenge the expectations placed on women of her time.

Becoming Madam Secretary by Stephanie Dray
Frances Perkins, America's first female cabinet secretary, defies convention to fight for social reform amid personal sacrifices and political opposition.


Book Club Talking Points
Marie Benedict's The Witch of Wall Street is perfect for book clubs. It is about a real woman, Hetty Green who many thought was a miser and a villain. However, she was actually very clever and outsmarted powerful men. Book clubs can explore questions like: Did she really deserve to be called a "witch," or was that just a way to put down a successful woman? How did her competitors shape the way history remembers her? What lessons can we learn from her experiences about ambition, money, and how we view reputation today?

The Witch of Wall Street by Marie Benedict-  Book Summary The Witch of Wall Street by Marie Benedict-  About the Author The Witch of Wall Street by Marie Benedict-  Book Club Discussion Questions

PBR book reviews and Reading guides for book clubs
10 Books I Can't Stop Recommending
Book blog- Immersive reads