This month, I am once again leaning into the multigenerational stories and character-driven sagas that have always been my favorite. Nearly every book I picked up pulled me in completely and is perfect for book clubs. And I finished more than a few with a kind of book anxiety where I just needed to find another just as good, fast
However, especially as we head into summer, I’ve also added a few books with a more relaxed and easygoing feel – books that prove a “summer read” doesn’t have to be light on substance. There’s a Gilded Age tragedy hidden beneath a pink cover and an atmospheric magical realism that definitely respects your intelligence.
To keep things balanced, there’s also a short literary read and a sharp puzzle to solve, plus more. Below are the 4-star and 5-star picks that earned their place in my blog post.
“Fairy tales are more than true: not because they tell us that dragons exist, but because they tell us that dragons can be beaten.”
― Neil Gaiman, Coraline
The Bright Years by Sarah Damoff
Rating ★★★★★
The Multigenerational Saga: Ryan and Lillian Bright are newly married and in love. But all is not as it seems; Lillian has a secret son, and Ryan has a drinking problem. Unfortunately, their daughter, Georgette, is a witness to this. As a result, she keeps her relationship with them at arm’s length. Years later, when Lillian’s son comes looking for his birth family, Georgette is pulled back into her family’s painful history. It’s a multigenerational story spanning sixty years – messy, but ultimately hopeful.
It’s an excellent choice for book clubs. The themes of addiction, secrets, and forgiveness give groups a lot to dig into – and Damoff, who is a social worker, writes about all of it with real compassion and zero judgment.
[Order your copy of The Bright Years]
[Read my full review of The Bright Years]
A Guardian and a Thief by Megha Majumdar
Rating ★★★★★
The Moral Dilemma: Set in a near-future Kolkata ravaged by climate change and food scarcity, a mother named Ma is just days away from flying to America to reunite her family – until her purse, holding their immigration documents, is stolen. The story unfolds over one week, following Ma’s desperate search, and Boomba, the thief, whose own family is in crisis and whose crimes keep escalating beyond his control. What makes it stick is that neither person is a villain – just two people doing whatever it takes to protect the people they love.
If you enjoy literary fiction that looks at social issues and complex characters, you will like this book. Plus, It is also a good pick for book clubs because it creates many discussion topics, such as class, moral compromise, and how people can act as both protectors and thieves at the same time.
[Order your copy of A Guardian and a Thief]
[Read my full review of A Guardian and a Thief]
Cleopatra by Saara El-Arifi
Rating ★★★★★
The Psychological Reimagining: Saara El-Arifi’s novel “Cleopatra” provides a deeper look at Cleopatra than the glamorous images often seen in Hollywood. The story does not focus only on her beauty and romantic relationships; it also shows her intelligence and the hard challenges she faces in a tough world. The book reveals the struggles Cleopatra encounters as a young woman trying to keep her power and identity.
Readers who enjoy strong female characters and immersive historical fiction will likely enjoy this book. Additionally, It’s also an excellent choice for book clubs because it opens discussions about power, gender, leadership, and how myth and storytelling often shape history – especially women’s history.
[Order your copy of Cleopatra]
[Read my full review of Cleopatra]
The First Witch of Boston by Andrea Catalano
Rating ★★★★★
The Grounded History: The First Witch of Boston by Andrea Catalano is a historical novel set in colonial New England, a time filled with fear and suspicion. The story follows a strong woman living in a dangerous period when rumors, religion, and power can quickly turn friends into enemies. It combines historical facts with emotional family struggles, making the story feel both close and unsettling.
If you enjoy historical fiction centered on women’s lives and morally complex characters, you will likely enjoy this book. It’s also a strong pick for book clubs because it raises thoughtful questions about fear, justice, prejudice, and how societies treat women who challenge expectations.
[Order your copy of The First Witch of Boston]
[Read my full review of The First Witch of Boston]
The It Girl by Allison Pataki
Rating ★★★★
The Gilded Age Tragedy: The It Girl by Allison Pataki follows the life of a young woman pulled into the glamorous, fast-changing world of twentieth-century high society. Beneath the fashion, parties, and public attention is a story about identity, ambition, and love. The novel mixes historical detail with emotional relationships and personal struggles.
This book is a great choice for book clubs that like exploring themes of glamour, toughness, and gender issues. Although the cover and title may seem light, the story offers a deep look at Evelyn Nesbit. Interestingly, she was a real person known as the “Gibson Girl” icon and for her connection to the “Crime of the Century.”
[Order your copy of The It Girl]
[Read my full review of The It Girl]
The Amalfi Curse by Sarah Penner
Rating ★★★★★
The Atmospheric Magical Realism: The Amalfi Curse by Sarah Penner is set along the stunning Amalfi Coast. The book centers on a young nautical archaeologist investigating shipwrecks in the hope of finding the priceless gems her father spoke of. One thing I really liked was how seamlessly it blends ancient legends and strong female characters into a story of danger and betrayal. The amazing setting and layered timeline make it an immersive read that’s easy to get lost in.
This book is great for those who enjoy historical fiction with a touch of magical realism. Book clubs will appreciate this book as it will spark conversations about the roles of women throughout history and how our past influences the present.
[Order your copy of The Amalfi Curse]
[Read my full review of The Amalfi Curse]
Marguerite by the Lake by Mary Dixie Carter
Rating ★★★★★
The Psychological Suspense: Phoenix has spent years as the gardener at Rosecliff, the stunning Connecticut estate of lifestyle icon Marguerite Gray – doing the real work while Marguerite takes the credit. After saving Marguerite’s husband, Geoffrey, from a falling tree, Phoenix gets pulled into an affair with him, and then Marguerite turns up dead. Now Phoenix has moved into the house, a detective is circling, and the first wife’s presence feels impossible to shake.
This book is a modern version of Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca. If your book club enjoys stories about class conflict, an overbearing first wife, and a mysterious house, you will like this one. Be aware that it focuses more on building a slow, gothic atmosphere rather than being a fast-paced thriller. It’s for readers who appreciate tension and a good mystery.
[Order your copy of Marguerite by the Lake]
[Read my full review of Marguerite by the Lake]
Strangers In Time By David Baldacci
Rating ★★★★
The Modern Puzzle: Strangers in Time by David Baldacci is a moving historical story set during World War II, following people whose lives unexpectedly cross paths during a time of fear and uncertainty. Rather than focusing on action or war strategy, the novel centers on human connection, survival, friendship, and the emotional impact of war on ordinary lives. Rather than focusing on action or war strategy, the novel centers on human connection, survival, friendship, and the emotional impact of war. Because of this, the characters are easy to become invested in, and the story balances heartbreak with hope.
This is a great choice for book clubs because of the tough moral choices the characters face. It’s also perfect for readers who enjoy suspenseful plots and strong character development.
[Order your copy of Strangers In Time]
[Read my full review of Strangers In Time]
Yellow Wife by Sadeqa Johnson
Rating ★★★★★
The Intense Essential (Backlist): Pheby was promised her freedom on her eighteenth birthday. Instead, she is taken from everything she knows and forced into a notorious slave jail in Virginia. There, she becomes the “yellow wife” of the jail’s harsh owner. She runs his household, has his children, and must constantly pretend to submit to keep herself and her children alive. This is a story of survival, sacrifice, and the difficult choices a woman makes when she has almost nothing but refuses to give up.
It’s a great fit for fans of historical fiction with strong female characters, comparable to The Kitchen House and Wench, and book clubs will find it particularly powerful for its exploration of a lesser-known chapter of American slavery. For me, the moral complexity of Pheby as a character – someone you both root for and are challenged by – makes for the best discussion.
[Order your copy of Yellow Wife]
[Read my full review of Yellow Wife]
You May Also Enjoy:
Before You Go: May’s Most Anticipated:
A quick reminder of the standout releases hitting shelves this month.
The Calamity Club
by Katheryn Stockett
Just released. This book explores the lives of often-overlooked women with humor and emotion. It highlights female friendships and societal views on women, making it great for book club discussions.
The Midnight Train
by Matt Haig
Coming soon. You will love this book for its emotional pull, relatable regrets, and its exploration of life choices, second chances, and what it really means to live a meaningful life.
